Community Opinion: Stop With Movie-Based Games!

By jalexbrown — September 17, 2009
Tags: movie-based-games opinion


An editorial discussing my opinions about why the game industry needs to stop making so many games based on movies.

Okay.  I hate to say it, but I will.  I'm a fiend for a creative product.  Call me crazy, call me stupid, call me a bad consumer, whatever.  If I have to wear these titles - and many others - because I dislike games based on movies, then so be it.

In the tough economic climate facing the US today, game publishers are more and more likely to push developers to use their pre-owned properties; it just so happens that a good chunk of these pre-owned properties are movie licenses.  I understand that there are a few games - and I'm using that term loosely, because it's actually a very select few - that are based on movie properties that make total sense; perhaps a few of these movies were begging to be made into a good game.  Take, for instance, The Godfather.  I love the game to death, and I happen to be a huge fan of the movie trilogy.  I happen to think that The Godfather was begging for a good sandbox experience, and the developers did a great job creating just that.  It's a great fun game that understood its own concept, executed it well, and managed to stick to the source material without becoming to constrained by it.  On the other end of the spectrum, developers today make a lot of games based on movies that just don't seem to stick too well with me.  As an example of that, let's use...any game based on a movie made by Pixar.  I'm sorry, but did Up really need a video game?  The truth is the publisher used that license to leach a moderate amount of success off of the movie.  It's not like you watch Up and think You know...this really should be made into a video game.

Blandness breeds blandness, and if the game industry doesn't decide to take chances and push away some of this mediocrity, we're going to have consoles with software lineups bloated with movie tie-ins and shovelware (whoops...sorry Wii...low blow).  My advice to the game developers is to take some chances, try to create some new properties, and I'm sure there are enough open-minded games out there who are willing to give it a shot.

Besides...if I'm wrong you can always go back to making Pixar tie-ins.

Comments
BatRastered

IMHO... If these games didn't make money, they wouldn't make them.

We should stop yelling at the studios and start yelling at the consumers who have to buy every game that has a picture of Hanna Montana on the cover (Jimmy!)

Vote with your wallets people!

Sep 18, 2009 by BatRastered

jalexbrown

The consumers who buy these games are the reason why so many good franchises
die young (Shenmue anyone?); the people buying these games don't know much of
anything about games. They're buying these games to please their five- and
six-year old kids who had to have the lastest Pixar tie-in or Hannah Montana
tie-in game. So yes, the studios do make a lot of money off of these travesties.
On the other hand, we as gamers have to suffer because the studios want to
appeal to the mass market. At some point they forgot what the set out to do,
which is make a good game. They might benefit from a lot of cash, and the kids
might benefit from tie-in products, but we as gamers suffer because we lose
the quality that we should be demanding.

Sep 18, 2009 by jalexbrown

SonicZero

only good example i know of, xmen origins wolverine

Feb 8, 2011 by SonicZero

Please log on to comment.

6e1a21b0-f834-423b-82c8-1f8cf4204884

Trending Video Games

 
Socialize
Final Fantasy XIV

FFXIV MasterDotL

FFXIV Macro